SC retains bar on Subrata Roy's foreign trips
Asks Sahara to reveal source of Rs 20k cr claimed to have been returned to investors
Jan 10, 2014
Source : Business Standard


DELHI: Retaining the bar on Sahara group chief Subrata Roy's visits abroad, the Supreme Court on Thursday asked his two real estate companies to disclose in two weeks the source of the Rs 20,000 crore these claimed to have refunded to the investors in their optionally fully-convertible debentures (OFCDs).

The companies, Sahara Housing Investment and Sahara India Real Estate,  maintain these have repaid 90 per cent of the investors. If that was so, the judges said, the source should have been reflected in their balance sheets.

The court had ordered the group to make refunds two years ago but, according to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), that has not been done.

The bench headed by K S Radhakrishnan told the Sahara counsel the companies would have to return the money. "Now we will call the registrar of companies to find the source of money and even order a CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) inquiry into the whole affair," the judge said.

"The court is not helpless; we will see our order is fully complied with," the bench said. The judges said the order to return the money was passed two years ago and nine months ago Sebi had moved the court for contempt action. "We don't want to burden Sebi any more," the judges said, threatening to take the matter to the Registrar of Companies, which, they said, was doing little in the matter.

"We have given maximum indulgence. We are driven to call the registrar," the court said. "If you take the history of the case, there is inconsistency in every affidavit filed by the Sahara companies. We have been most generous in this matter, but you don't appreciate our indulgence."

Though the court expected the companies to provide sufficient securities in the nature of title deeds of assets to guarantee the refund, Sebi counsel Arvind Datar on Thursday said all the property titles were shaky. The Aamby Valley project in Maharashtra was riddled with litigation and false power-of-attorney transactions, for which a key person had been arrested. Also, the entire project was without environment clearance and litigation for this was pending, he said.

Some other properties in other parts of the country had also been valued exorbitantly to meet the court's demand for adequate security. In several cases, the property was bought for a sum and thevaluation showed more than 50 times appreciation over 10 years. Some deeds were not traceable, Datar said.

In view of the objections of Sebi about the title deeds, there was no arguments about Roy going out on business as the permission was conditional on sufficient security to the satisfaction  of Sebi.

Sebi had raised contempt action with regard to Sahara’s advertisements in all leading papers about the pending cases.  The court had at last hearing ordered publication  of apology in all the papers with equal prominence. The judges said in a lighter vein that they read all the newspapers and they have not been able to spot any apology so far. It should be done before Janauray 28, when the case will be heard again, after the production of title deeds with adequate security.

Latest Realty News

Panel for expansion of registration requirement of CERSAI
Jan 10, 2014
DELHI: A working group appointed by Central Registry, CERSAI, has advocated for expanding scope of registration to movable assets including jewellery as well.
Why you need brokerage services while buying property
Jan 10, 2014
DELHI: While purchasing a property, it always helps to have someone who knows the market inside-out. A genuine property brokerage firm fills in this gap between you and the market. Let’s find out the reasons one should opt for such a firm:
Housing projects allowed in Gurgaon’s commercial zones
Jan 09, 2014
DELHI: In what will give a boost to construction activity in NCR, particularly Gurgaon, the Haryana government has decided to allow mixed land use in commercial zones notified in the master plan. The government’s move will allow realtors to build residential properties in commercial complexes.
123 properties in prime locations in Delhi may go to Wakf Board
Jan 09, 2014
DELHI: The urban development ministry has prepared a draft cabinet note to denotify 123 properties in prime locations in Delhi, and to transfer the ownership rights to the Delhi Wakf Board in a way annulling their acquisition by the British government between 1911 and 1915.
Bharat Hospitality launches five star hotel Lalit in Chandigarh
Jan 09, 2014
DELHI: Bharat Hospitality group that owns the Lalit hotel chain has opened its doors in Chandigarh. The Lalit Chandigarh, a five star property with 179 keys was set up with an investment of Rs. 400 crore. The property is spread across four acres in Chandigarh's Rajiv Gandhi IT Park.
Office leasing activity in Delhi-NCR picked up pace in October-December 2013: CBRE
Jan 09, 2014
DELHI: Absorption of prime office space in the National Capital Region (NCR) grew around 14% in the October-December 2013 quarter compared to the previous quarter, touching 1.7 million sq ft, according to property consultancy CBRE. The previous quarter saw a total leasing of 1.5 million sq ft.
DIPP to soon float revised cab note on FDI in construction
Jan 08, 2014
DELHI: The commerce and industry ministry will soon float a revised cabinet note on relaxation of FDI norms for the construction sector.
Should you prepay a home loan before you retire?
Jan 08, 2014
DELHI: Manoj Pradhan, who is set to retire in five years, has two properties. Since he has taken a home loan, one of these is mortgaged with the bank. He gets a concessional rate as he is a bank employee and hasn't prepaid the loan. He is banking on his pension, rent and investment returns for post-retirement needs. He isn't sure if he should repay the loan before he retires or allow it to continue. He needs help in taking the decision.
LARR Act: NAREDCO suggests amendments
Jan 08, 2014
DELHI: The intent of the Act seems to set standard norms for the transfer of land in order to free such deals of any dispute and thereby facilitate land transfers. However, the terms laid out within the Act are impractical and bound to result in avoidable delays and exponential cost increases, which defeat the very purpose of the Act.
Brigade Group buys 2.25 acre plot in Bangalore for Rs 69 crore
Jan 08, 2014
DELHI: Realty firm Brigade Enterprises has bought 2.25 acres of land in Bangalore from Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages for almost Rs 69 crore.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's