CJI moves Cidco hotel plot case to another bench
Mar 25, 2014
Source : The Times of India


MUMBAI: A Supreme Court bench, headed by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) P Sathasivam, on Monday requested a two-judge bench, headed by Justice Gyan Sudha Misra, not to hear a matter listed before it for a day after lawyers representing the City and Industrial Development Corporation (Cidco) complained of forum-hunting and sought de-tagging of its case.

The electronic board scroll flashed that "item 11" in court number 10 will not be heard and by evening, the SC registry placed the matter on Tuesday's board before a different bench of Justice AK Patnaik and Justice F M I Kalifulla in court number five at serial number 23. Forum-hunting refers to the search for an adjudicating body, in this case a bench, of one's choice.

The case involves an appeal against a Bombay HC order which set aside a 2011 decision by Cidco to cancel its 2008 allotment of 12 acres of land in Seawoods, Navi Mumbai, to Metropolis Hotels, a part of the group company led by Pune developer Avinash Bhosale.

The HC had upheld the allotment to Metropolis Hotels, which won the bid and later sold part of the plot to Shishir Realty for Rs 260 crore with a Rs 1.38 crore transfer fee to Cidco. The land meant for a hotel was changed for commercial and residential use.

Cidco filed a special leave petition (SLP) against the HC judgment, but it has yet to be numbered and its paper book has to clear administrative queries from the SC registry.

On Monday, Cidco's counsel Dushyant Dave and Ajit Bhasme informed the SC that there seems to be a modus operandi at forum-hunting with the CJI becoming an "unwitting party" though he acted in good faith. Senior counsel Harish Salve supported his submission. The CJI said the matter would be looked into.

Last week, a lawyer for Shishir Realty told the Cidco lawyer that its SLP would be heard along with a plea filed by H K Sudhakara—not a party in the Cidco case in HC—seeking permission to file an SLP in the matter, by a bench headed by Justice Misra on March 24. In January, Sudhakara's plea, mentioned by senior counsel V K Bali, was clubbed with a civil contempt case emanating from an unrelated UP case ruling before Justice Misra's bench. Bali later withdrew the contempt.

A day before the Holi holiday, senior counsel Mukul Rohtagi of Shishir Realty, sought the CJI bench and got the Cidco SLP tagged with Sudhakara's plea before Justice Misra's bench with no notice.

Latest Realty News

Panchshil signs brand licensing for premium residential projects
Mar 25, 2014
PUNE: Pune-based real estate developer Panchshil Realty, has signed brand licensing agreement with another real estate Pune based developer Elite Landmarks to develop mid size apartments in Pune. According to Panchshil, this is a first-of-its-kind brand licensing in India.
Tata Steel’s 25-acre land parcel fetches Rs 1,155 crore
Mar 25, 2014
MUMBAI: Steel major Tata Steel's 25-acre land parcel in Borivali suburb of Mumbai has fetched the highest bid of Rs1,155 crore in an e-auction concluded late Monday, said three persons familiar with the development. Realty majors Lodha Group, Oberoi RealtyBSE -2.96 %, Kalpataru Properties and Tata Group company Tata Housing Development Co were in the race to acquire the property. It is believed that Tata Housing has offered the highest bid. However, this could not be confirmed independently.
Realty companies wake up to brand value, challenge infringement
Mar 25, 2014
MUMBAI: Real estate developers in India have started challenging possible infringement of their brand names established over the years, joining their counterparts in sectors such as pharmaceuticals and consumer goods that are known to make serious efforts to promote and protect their distinctive identities.
Mumbai flat buyers at mercy of property developers
Mar 25, 2014
MUMBAI: Flat buyers often find themselves at the mercy of property developers. Unscrupulous builders are known to suddenly turn around and demand additional money from purchasers when the time comes to hand over possession of the flat.
Oberoi Realty, Kalpataru in race for Tata Steel plot
Mar 25, 2014
MUMBAI: Real estate developers Oberoi Realty and Kalpataru have emerged front runners in a race to acquire Tata Steel’s 25-acre plot here.
Routine civic work hit by poll duties tax recovery disturb AMC's routine work
Mar 24, 2014
AURANGABAD: The civic body's routine work has literally come to a standstill for the past few days with most of its officers and employees engaged in election duties.
IDFC Alternatives mops up ?750 crore for maiden realty fund
Mar 24, 2014
MUMBAI: IDFC Alternatives, a wholly owned subsidiary of infrastructure finance company IDFC, has raised Rs 750 crore from domestic investors for its maiden real estate fund. The performance, despite the slowdown in the economy, exceeded the company’s expectations.
Navi Mumbai: A rise in capital values in Nerul, Airoli and Palm Beach
Mar 24, 2014
MUMBAI: Looking to invest in Navi Mumbai? Nerul, Airoli and Palm Beach, are localities that offer property investments that garner constant returns. According to MagicBricks.com data, these localities have witnessed a hike of 12-19 per cent in capital values in the last one year. Property experts say that the clearance of the proposed Navi Mumbai Airport is the factor that has pushed property prices in these localities.
Realty’s online mantra
Mar 24, 2014
MUMBAI: When the great online shopping festival took place last year, where everything, from a pin to a plasma television (quite literally) was sold online, little did people know that they would end up buying expensive items like cars or even a home, for that matter, through that medium. Today, it is not uncommon to see niche and high-value categories, such as jewellery, automobile and real estate, featuring among the best deals online. According to a Google estimate, the online retailing marke
Urban Development Department,UDD,UDISSMT,Small And Medium Towns Scheme
Mar 22, 2014
AURANGABAD: With the current financial year coming to an end, principal secretary of the state urban development department (UDD) on Friday asked the heads of respective municipal bodies across the Marathwada region to improve the collection figures of various taxes. Till date, the collection figures through property tax stands at 47% and 32% through water tax.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's