Campa residents see hope in SC’s remark
Jul 10, 2014
Source : The Times of India


MUMBAI: The residents of Worli’s Campa Cola Compound believe that the Supreme Court’s latest observations have offered them a ray of hope. But legal experts are cautious in their opinion on whether this paves the way for regularization of the unauthorized floors of the compound’s buildings.

In its February 2013 order, the apex court had said that the residents had failed to make out a case to direct the BMC to regularize the constructions.

“We would like to reiterate that no authority administering municipal laws and other similar laws can encourage violation of the sanctioned plan. The courts are also expected to refrain from exercising equitable jurisdiction for regularization of illegal and unauthorized constructions; else, it would encourage violators of the planning laws and destroy the very idea and concept of planned development of urban as well as rural areas,” a division bench of Justices G S Singhvi and S J Mukhopadhaya had said, adding, “The corporation (BMC) is expected to take action in the matter at the earliest.”

On July 7, a bench of Justices S J Mukhopadhaya and S A Bobde told the BMC’s counsel that the court never told the residents to vacate and only said that the flats were unauthorized; also, it had not specifically directed the BMC to demolish the illegal portions of the buildings. “So, it is for the BMC to take action as per law, but no contempt of court is made out,” it said, advising the BMC and the residents to work out, within the legal framework, a settlement on sympathetic grounds.

According to IPS officer-turned-lawyer Y P Singh, the apex court had only said that no contempt was made out and its February 2013 order dismissing the residents’ plea challenging the BMC’s demolition orders had achieved finality. “The BMC now has to implement the demolition orders,” said Singh.

He said an out-of-court settlement to regularize the illegal structures would be difficult and has to be done within the law. “The issue is of floor space index (FSI) violations and the development control regulations are stringent and do not allow for any relaxation. Also, there is no scope for regularization unless the residents can show additional land attached to the plot. However, Coastal Regulation Zone rules do not allow for amalgamation. So it’s not just the BMC, but the Union ministry of environment and forests that is involved and whose approval is required. It is not going to be easy.”

Advocate Jamshed Mistry, who practises in the high court, believes the Supreme Court has inherent powers and even after the February 2013 order, a solution that is within the parameters of law could be found. “Nothing prevents the court from making a suggestion to explore if a way out can be found,” he said. Campa residents are holding on to this hope.

Latest Realty News

Rail Budget to push Mum-Ahd bullet train
Jul 10, 2014
MUMBAI: The first Mumbai-Ahmedabad high-speed train proposal may get a push in the new government’s maiden rail Budget considering PM Narendra Modi’s promise of a diamond quadrilateral of bullet trains to connect the four major cities of Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata and Chennai.
Realtors seek reforms to pep up sector
Jul 10, 2014
PUNE: Granting the real-estate sector the status of an industry, interest rate subvention to encourage home buyers and higher tax deductions for home loan and interest on these loans top the wishlist of city-based realtors ahead of the Budget on Wednesday.
Piramal raises Rs 100 crore for residential realty fund
Jul 09, 2014
MUMBAI: Ajay Piramal-led Piramal Fund Management today said it has raised Rs 100 crore in a fund, which will be focusing on residential real estate investments.
Mahindra makes a bold bet on affordable homes
Jul 09, 2014
MUMBAI : The Mahendra group's recent foray into affordable housing is significant for two reasons. For one, it is after a long hiatus that a big business house has ventured into real estate. In the 1990s, many large groups, especially those with land banks in prime locations, had drawn up fancy plans for the sector but quietly retreated when they realised the complexities of the business. (Land is a state subject and so, each market has its own sets of rules and regulations. There are, therefore
Thane, Navi Mumbai flat prices up 85%
Jul 09, 2014
MUMBAI: A five-year price analysis of residential realty market in 11 cities shows that the ever-expanding Navi Mumbai and Thane have registered the highest percentage of increase in home prices across the country. They are followed by Mumbai.
SC: Deal with Campa Cola as per law
Jul 09, 2014
MUMBAI: The Supreme Court on July 7 did not agree with the BMC that residents of unauthorized flats in Worli’s Campa Cola Compound have committed contempt of court by not vacating their residential units in disregard of the SC’s February 27 judgment.
Mumbai: Residential demand increases in eastern suburb
Jul 07, 2014
MUMBAI: The hitherto low-profile eastern suburb of Mumbai, starting from Kurla to Thane on the Lal Bahadur Shastri Marg, is fast becoming the next commercial hub of the city with tiny office complexes and new-age retail destinations, giving tough competition to its southern and western counterparts such as Nariman Point, Worli-Lower Parel and Bandra-Kurla Complex, among others.
Housing Prices Can Fall on Transparency, Timely Approvals: HDFC
Jun 20, 2014
Calling for major reforms in housing sector, HDFC chairman Deepak Parekh has said transparency and timely approvals from different authorities can reduce home prices by almost 20 per cent.
Brahma Management to invest Rs 3,000 crore in Indian real estate sector
Jun 20, 2014
Nine years after it was formed, New York-based Brahma Management has lined up big investments for the Indian real estate market . Brahma, an FDI-funded investment and asset management company, has already invested around Rs 2,500 crore in the sector and has plans to put in another Rs 3,000 crore over the next two years.
Mahindra Lifespaces ventures into affordable housing segment
Jun 20, 2014
Mahindra Lifespaces Developers, the real estate arm of the Mahindra group, on Monday launched its new business vertical 'Happinest' that will focus on developing affordable housing projects.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's