Flat sale in the VAT net
Nov 06, 2013
Source : The Hindu


MUMBAI: Recently, in the case of Larsen & Toubro, the Larger Bench ruled that Value Added Tax (VAT) would apply on “under-construction property”, and upheld two earlier decisions from the Supreme Court and the Bombay High Court.

The judgement essentially dealt with VAT applicability on building contracts, a species of works contract, which has been a matter of constant dispute/ litigation.

Like in the earlier case of Raheja Development Corporation, L&T developed the property of a landowner under an arrangement to provide 25 per cent of the developed space to the owner, with the rest going to the company. Based on a power of attorney, L&T entered into sale agreements with prospective buyers, who would gain possession of a fully-built flat along with an undivided interest in the land.

The point to consider was whether such a sale agreement would attract VAT as a tax on transfer of property in the goods involved in the execution of the works contract. The main grievance was that the construction of flats/ apartments was not at the behest of the buyer but on the developer/ owner’s account. Hence, even if there is a transfer of property in the goods used in the construction, it is to the self and not the prospective buyer on the basis of the accretion principle. Also, what is eventually conveyed is an immovable property.

However, Revenue authorities contended that the judgement in the Raheja case was correct, and that after the 46th Constitutional Amendment, the tax on sale of goods to include transfer of property in goods involved in the execution of works contract, whether as goods or in some other form, was wide enough to cover the value of goods involved in immovable property.

While upholding the Revenue department’s arguments, the Larger Bench laid out/ reiterated several legal positions, including

The term ‘works contract’ in Article 366(29-A)(b) is not restricted to what is traditionally understood — that is, only contracts involving labour or service.

In a composite contract comprising works contract and transfer of immovable property, sales tax can be levied on value of material involved in the execution of works contract.

The dominant nature test does not apply to cases involving works contract, even though the dominant intention of such a contract could be provision of service or conveyance of immovable property. The dominant intention theory should still apply to determine whether the composite contract not involving work contract is a sale contract or service contract. For example, during a medical implant surgery there is an incidental transfer of property.

Importantly, it is held that taxing the sale of goods is permissible even after its incorporation in the immovable property, provided the tax is directed only to the value of goods during incorporation.

Very importantly, it is clarified that works contract would arise only from the stage at which the developer enters into a contract with the flat buyer. Thus, tax is chargeable only on the value of the materials involved and transferred after an agreement is entered into with the buyer. This would be difficult to implement. What will happen to the composition methods of taxation, calculated on the entire contract value? Can the taxpayer rework the contract value to a lower value after entering an agreement to sell? In Tamil Nadu, the general practice is to charge (though not explicitly shown as not permitted to recover) the composition rate on the total value or even in other schemes — namely, the merit route or ad hoc route — to pay tax on the entire value of material involved, irrespective of whether it is before or after the construction agreement. Is this to be revisited?

Finally, as held in the Raheja judgement, there will be no works contract if the agreement is entered into after the flat or unit is already constructed. The question over when a flat or unit is already constructed can again become contentious.

While the judgement has provided finality on the taxability of under-construction property, it has left a trail of other issues to be resolved.

Latest Realty News

Realty sector: A new pressure point
Nov 06, 2013
MUMBAI: In his first full-fledged review of the monetary policy, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Raghuram Rajan stuck to the continuing hawkish stance of inflation control first, which has seen the repo rate go up by another 25 basis points. The repo rate is the rate at which the central bank lends money (liquidity) to the financial system, and is the key policy rate. After the RBI action on October 29, it stands at 7.75 per cent.
The missing link in new Reit regulations
Nov 06, 2013
MUMBAI: Recently, the Securities and Exch-ange Board of India's Chairman, UK Sinha said that if Reits have to succeed, they will have to be tax-efficient. He further said he will ask tax-authorities to consider tax incentives for real estate investment trusts. "We'll talk to the I-T department to make it happen," he added.
Pune builders to transfer ownership of flats or will get blacklisted
Nov 06, 2013
PUNE: The Pimpri Chinchwad New Township Development Authority (PCNTDA) administration has warned as many as 375 builders saying that the builders would be blacklisted if they fail to transfer the ownership of the flats, constructed by them, in the buyers’ name through conveyance deed in the next three months.
No progress in making building approvals public
Nov 06, 2013
MUMBAI: It was in 2009 that the then municipal commissioner Jairaj Phatak introduced a system whereby all building plans would be submitted on a compact disc and permissions and concessions granted online. The approved plans then were to be displayed on the BMC’s website for citizens to know what had been sanctioned.
‘Vacancy levels in malls down in July-Sept quarter’
Nov 06, 2013
MUMBAI: The vacancy levels in malls have come down to 14.51 per cent in the July-September quarter due mainly to a decline in the supply of new mall space, a recent report said.
Premium housing prices may fall soon on inventory pile-up
Nov 05, 2013
MUMBAI: Investors can look forward to premium housing units getting cheaper by up to 20 per cent and gold prices rising significantly this festive season, says a financial advisory firm.
Large office spaces see few takers as slowdown bites
Nov 05, 2013
MUMBAI: The quantum of large commercial space leased out dipped sharply last quarter. While Delhi saw a drop of 91% sequentially and 66% over the March quarter, the trend in Mumbai was only slightly better — the fall was 50% sequentially and 62% over the January-March period. Indeed, there seem to be few takers for office space of more than 1 lakh square feet — just 1.2 lakh sq ft was rented in Delhi in the September quarter while in Mumbai the area was 2.5 lakh sq ft.
Equity, gold, real estate: Tips to make your first investments
Nov 05, 2013
MUMBAI: It is not an easy time to be an investor. Even though you may be spoilt for choice, there is a high degree of volatility across asset classes. This means that one has to be extra cautious while choosing investments. Whether you are opting for equity, fixed income, property or gold, the current environment will punish you for rash or untimely decisions. For those who have just started saving, taking the initial steps into the world of investing is even more daunting. It's the same for any
Festive season brings relief to real estate, automobile market
Nov 04, 2013
NASHIK: At a time when the industrial and real estate sectors have been facing economic slowdown since the last two years, the festive season from Dussehra to Diwali brought relief to real estate and automobile sectors. From October 5 to November 3, these sectors generated business worth over Rs 300 crore in the city.
Land surveyor held for taking Rs 3,000 bribe
Nov 04, 2013
NASHIK: Even as the anti-corruption bureau's (ACB) Vigilance Awareness Week was underway, the ACB sleuths last Thursday arrested a land surveyor in Yaval tehsil of Jalgaon while accepting a bribe of Rs 3,000 from a woman.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's