Salgaocar brothers move High Court over property dispute
Oct 11, 2013
Source : The Economic Times


MUMBAI: The Salgaocar brothers, one of Goa's biggest business groups, are locked in a battle over separation of the group's assets after one brother accused the other of reneging on a signed agreement.

Shivanand Salgaocar, son of Vasudev Salgaocar, who founded the mines-to-hotels group in the 1950s, has filed a petition in the Bombay High Court asking that a settlement agreed upon by the two brothers be implemented.

He has alleged that the family of Dattaraj Salgaocar had walked out of the agreement, claiming that the agreement was "tax evasive".

At stake are two family mansions in Goa, several offices, iron ore mines, a hotel business and ships worth hundreds of crores.

The case came up for hearing on Thursday. Justice SJ Kathawala said he will hear the petition filed by Shivanand against his brother Dattaraj on October 17. Mumbai-based law firm Dastur Dadhich & Kalambi is representing Shivanand while younger brother Dattaraj is being represented by two law firms - Gagrat & Company and Federal & Rashmikant

The Economic Times has reviewed the petition. ET tried to reach Shivanand who responded saying he's travelling abroad and asked us to get in touch with his office. Dattaraj Salgaocar in an email response to our queries said: "I have no comments to offer as the matter is sub judice."

The crux of the dispute is the memorandum of understanding by the two groups reached in October 2009. This proposal divided the family businesses and business assets and properties into the mining business and hotel business referred in the petition as 'business baskets'.

The MoU also provided for the segregation and division of the family businesses, the estate and the two family residential properties, and the steps needed to be taken to implement the division. The petition said that several resolutions were later passed by Salgaocar group companies to facilitate the settlement.

"Both the families were almost reaching a settlement but then we don't know what happened," said a person involved in the case, and declined to give more details citing it family's internal matter. "We are hoping to get it settled very soon."

Dattaraj is married to Dipti, the sister of Mukesh and Anil Ambani. Officials from both the Reliance groups appeared to have helped in the original agreement.

Shivanand's petition says that the division of assets was initially a smooth affair. "With professional advice of Atul Dayal, Gautam Doshi and tax and financial advisors KPMG, Dattaraj Salgaocar for himself and on behalf of his group consciously chose and elected to take the hotel business basket."

A written communication (letter of election) dated December 11, 2009, of the binding acceptance of the hotel basket and signed by Dattaraj Salgaocar was sent to the Shivanand faction.

The Shivanand group also agreed to infuse 385 crore into the hotel business and borrowed 100 crore from friends and associates to make the payment.

The VM Salgaocar Group was founded by late Vasudev Salgaocar in 1950s that made its wealth through its mining operations. They are mainly engaged in mining and iron ore export with interests in shipping, real estate, hospitality, agriculture, media and healthcare. The group's website says that it is one of the leading Indian suppliers of processed iron ore to the world's largest steel makers NSC and POSCO besides other steel mills in China, Romania, and the Middle East.

"Wealth management through generations has become difficult to manage in today's world," says Mita Dixit, co-founder and head of family business advisory at Equations Management. "In many cases, with generation next entering the family business after studying abroad they would like to do something very different from their family business, which becomes tipping point for separation."

The group also has several trusts that run schools, colleges, hospital and Goa's famous Salgaocar Football team.



Latest Realty News

Pragmatism to drive Mumbai’s realty growth
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: Statistics may highlight the rising realty inventory but the undercurrent in the Mumbai property market indicates that revival is very much on the cards.
MMRDA ropes in S Korea for eastern Mumbai development planning
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: The Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) has signed an agreement with South Korea for the preparation of a master plan for developing the eastern parts of the city along the proposed 126-km long Virar-Alibaug multi-modal corridor.
Charoli delivers ultimate real estate location to Pune
Oct 10, 2013
PUNE: Location is everything in real estate – and never more so than in Pune, one of India’s most exciting and active real estate markets. The Oxford of the East has been steadily gaining a larger and larger share of the country’s IT and ITeS pie, and is now all set to surpass even Bangalore. At the same time, real estate market in Pune is further bolstered by its thriving manufacturing industry as well as education and healthcare sectors.
Crucial realty document is yours only if you pay dues
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: Seeking the copy of a property registration card (PRC) at the land records office can prove to be a costly affair. A PRC is a land record which provides the complete history of past owners as well as current owners. It is an invaluable document for land-owners to prove ownership. With the Right to Information Act, 2005, any citizen can seek the PRC of any plot. It is here that the catch lies.
Proper notice must to hike property tax
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation cannot hike property tax without serving proper notice on the property’s owner or occupier, the Bombay high court has said. Eleven years after the BMC asked some Girgaum residents to pay extra tax, Justice S S Shinde came to their aid and said the pasting of notice on the property “cannot be accepted”.
Sofitel eyes 10 properties in India in couple of years
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: Sofitel, a French luxury hotel chain managed by Accor Group, is eyeing 10 properties in India, mainly in prime luxury destinations, in a couple of years, a top company executive said.
Bombay High Court to decide on transfer of Lavasa case to green tribunal
Oct 10, 2013
MUMBAI: The Bombay High Court today said it would decide whether the case pertaining to alleged irregularities by Lavasa township near Pune can be transferred to the National Green Tribunal, set up to handle environment protection related issues.
Now, BMC to form buildings safety panel
Oct 09, 2013
MUMBAI: In the wake of the building collapse in Mazagaon, the BMC will form a standard technical advisory committee (STAC) to monitor building safety in a scientific manner. This committee will function on the lines of the civic body’s STAC for roads and will play a crucial role in deciding the nature of dangerous categories for dilapidated buildings in the city.
Andheri East is an attractive proposition for Mumbai homebuyers
Oct 08, 2013
MUMBAI: Andheri east has gained prominence in both, residential and commercial segments lately. It is an industrial area and also a MIDC-SEEPZ zone. The Chhatrapati Shivaji International Airport is an important landmark here. The upcoming Mumbai metro and its close proximity to the western express highway ensure that any project here will see increasing valuations over the years. Ramesh Nair, managing director west, Jones Lang LaSalle India, says, “The area has now become a hot property destinat
Right time to invest in the Goregaon-Borivali growth corridor
Oct 08, 2013
MUMBAI: For people looking for well-designed living spaces with beautiful landscapes, the glitziest malls and commercial outlets – all within a walking distance, Goregaon west is the ideal location. Off the western express highway, Goregaon west has emerged as an upscale commercial and residential destination in the western corridor of Mumbai.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's