The case for a land value tax
The real estate bubble will not burst anytime soon, but capital is being hit as nothing new is created
Jan 29, 2014
Source : The Hindu

 

MYSORE: In a feudal society like India, land ownership has always been a source of wealth and power.

While the traditional feudal class has largely faded out, post-Independence, especially in the last decade, real estate prices have soared to vertiginous heights, bringing realty back to the centre stage of the Indian economy.

The fall in property prices in 11 out of 15 major Indian cities in 2013 as compared to 2012, has created a feeling that the overheated real estate sector is showing signs of correction. Some have gone on to speculate that this might be the sign of an impending real estate bubble- burst. But bankers see no reason to be worried as the Indian realty sector differs from that of developed world in many ways.

First, the mortgaged property’s market value is more than its book value as up to 50 per cent of the value of a property is paid by the buyer in “black”, and banks lend only by book value. So the sector can absorb considerable downward correction. Secondly, a major share of the investment in real estate is in undeveloped land, which is not financed by banks. Finally, money is parked in this sector usually to evade taxes, and this flow of unaccounted funds is not likely to slow down anytime soon.

It is a tragedy that the same factors which make this sector immune to a meltdown, are bleeding our economy. Black money, whether earned legitimately or siphoned off from government-spending, is getting sucked into a vortex of shady land deals, which provide not only anonymity but assured returns. It creates artificial scarcity, jacking up land prices for end-users. Moreover, it creates an incentive for the builder-politician nexus to delay clearances to residential or commercial building projects of individuals or communities without political patronage, leading to a mushrooming of irregular colonies, with non-existent infrastructure such as water lines and sewerage.

It has created a new feudal class of landowners which extracts a rentier’s income from the economy without adding any value. The overdeveloped real estate sector is worthless for India’s balance of trade, as construction projects, even if world-class, cannot be exported. Even if the real estate bubble does not burst, capital is still being destroyed and nothing new is created.

This is the neo-liberal blind spot which fails to see the Physiocrat’s wisdom of recognising that productive work is the only source of national wealth.

However, the productive work, the value added to the economy, is all that most modern economies tax. Real estate, on the other hand, gets its value from location, mostly a result of public utilities like transportation, water, electricity and drainage tending it, and jobs, schools and hospitals in its vicinity. All of this is financed by the community, either as taxes if built by the state, or as user-fees if built privately. So modern taxation is a clear case of taxing private wealth while doling out public wealth to a select few — those who are first-comers, inheritors, cronies or plain lucky.

The logical solution to this aberration would be to tax land at its value. The so-called land value tax was an idea considered by Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations, but most famously and fervently advocated by George Smith. Ever since the 1868 Meiji restoration in Japan, it has been used in many parts of the world, as in the U.S., Australia and Hong Kong. It has been dubbed ‘the least bad tax’ by Milton Friedman as it does not lead to allocative inefficiency. From Paul Samuelson to Joseph Stiglitz, it has many supporters in the economists’ fraternity. Michael Hudson is a vocal proponent and he has suggested it for China as a way to avoid the fate of debt-ridden Western economies.

Land value tax, when applied to non-agricutural land, might turn out to be the game-changer. It will end speculative land hoarding and bring down prices for the end-user. The money saved thus will be spent on other commodities, increasing consumption and give the economy a boost. It will free a lot of undeveloped land close to cities, which can be developed by state or private players. These developed colonies will be affordable to lower income families which have been spending considerable sums for unapproved land till now.

This will provide the government revenues to develop urban infrastructure. Mining companies, which find it more profitable to squat on natural reserves sensing a rise in mineral prices, will not do that once they have to pay annual tax on the value of the mines. They will have to mine it to earn revenue to pay tax, or choose to return it to the government. Unused prime urban land, of closed mills for example, will be promptly returned to the government for the same reason.

This tax may not replace all other taxes, as Paul Krugman concedes, but may be a one-stop solution to all that ails realty sectors.

Latest Realty News

RBI seeks to control inflation: India Inc
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: The Reserve Bank of India's move to increase repo rate by 0.25 basis points is aimed to control rising prices rather than encouraging economic growth, say CEOs.
10 things to watch for in the commodities space
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: Citi commodity research has come out with a report highlighting 10 areas that should be watched as they will have an impact on the world’s largest commodity consumer with 40 per cent market share. These factors could shape commodity prices and demand outlook in the coming months and years.
Business leaders decry rate rise
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI)'s raising of the repo rate (at which it lends to banks for the short term) by 0.25 basis points is aimed to control rising prices rather than to encourage economic growth, say chief executives (CEOs) of companies.
BMC’s preparatory report for ‘Development Plan’ made public
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: The Municipal Corporation has undertaken the work of revision of the ‘Development Plan’ for Greater Mumbai for the 2014-2034 period (20 years). The work of revision of the ‘Development Plan’ is being carried out by municipal engineers, urban planning consultants and M/s Groupe SCE(I) Ltd. As a part of this exercise, the work of Existing Land Use survey (ELU) was completed in the year 2012 and the same was also thrown open to the public for comments till March 30, 2013. The comments recei
Home away from home near Mumbai
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: Owning a home is considered one of the most important investment decisions for anyone. Purchasing a second home is thus, the second most important decision. Having an asset that provides rental income can mean long-term financial security. In addition, appreciation in capital values can result in a significant corpus via sale of the asset, if and when needed. Many second home buyers from Mumbai also invest in second homes, primarily for the convenience of having a weekend getaway or to a
PE for the mid-income housing segment in tier-II and III cities
Jan 29, 2014
MUMBAI: Tier-I cities in India have seen tremendous growth over the past several years and are now close to saturation in terms of their ability to offer sustainably lucrative investment opportunities in various industries. Tier-II and III cities, on the other hand, still boast of relatively untapped demand in various industries, which is only going to get accentuated over time, as these cities witness progressively higher growth enabled by concerted attention from a range of players.
Pune’s Koregaon Park: The elite’s delight
Jan 29, 2014
PUNE: Koregaon Park is arguably the swankiest and among the most expensive real estate destinations in Pune. Even before the Osho Commune was established here in the 1970s, it was a location of choice for bungalows. After the arrival of the Commune, it became one of the primary congregation hubs for multinational travellers. The existence of the Osho Commune has transformed Koregaon Park beyond recognition. It now has its own identity, which is very different from that of any other area in Pune.
Banking, realty stocks gain ahead of RBI policy
Jan 28, 2014
MUMBAI: Key benchmark indices trimmed gains after hitting intraday high in morning trade. The barometer index, the S&P BSE Sensex, was up 39.94 points or 0.19%, off 29.12 points from the day's high and up 33.17 points from the day's low. The market breadth, indicating the overall health of the market, was strong.
Sebi unhappy with fund houses' efforts to increase reach
Jan 28, 2014
MUMBAI: Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has raised concern over lack of efforts shown by mutual fund houses to penetrate beyond the top cities, despite the extra incentives provided by the regulator.
Long-term policy for mutual funds very soon: Sebi
Jan 28, 2014
MUMBAI: Sebi Chairman U K Sinha today said the market watchdog will shortly come out with a long-term policy for the mutual fund industry which will help deepen the penetration of the industry into non-metro markets.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's