CCI Rejects Charges Against Jaypee Group; 2 Members Dissent
Oct 29, 2015

New Delhi: By a majority order, the Competition Commission of India has dismissed charges of dominant market position abuse against Jaiprakash Associates in the real estate sector.

Dissenting with the majority decision, two members of the fair trade regulator said a penalty of Rs 666 crore should be imposed as the company was in violation of competition norms. However, this was overruled by the CCI Chairman and two other members who said the JP group was not a dominant player in the relevant market - that is development and sale of residential units in their 'integrated townships' in Noida and Greater Noida.

The competition watchdog also asked the company and other players in the realty sector to take appropriate voluntary measures to address the concerns of the flat buyers.

CCI Chairman Ashok Chawla and two members - Sudhir Mital and U C Nahta - said that JP Associates and Jaypee Infratech Ltd did not "enjoy a position of dominance in the market for provision of services for the development and sale of residential apartments in Noida and Greater Noida".

Dissenting with the majority order, two CCI members - S L Bunker and Augustine Peter - ruled that JP Group enjoyed dominant position in this case and directed it to "cease and desist" from indulging in anti-competitive practices.

The 137-page order came after CCI's probe into the alleged abuse of dominant position with regard to development and sale of residential units in JP Group's integrated townships in Noida and Greater Noida.

According to the majority order, the investigation by CCI's Director General found that the market share of Jaypee Group was much less than the rival competitor and it did not have any commercial advantage over its competitors due to its economic strength or due to its size or resources.

Quoting the DG's investigation, this order said Jaypee Group was behind Amrapali, its next rival competitor, and "this clearly demonstrates that it (Jaypee) does not have the biggest market shares in the relevant market".

The minority order, however, said that DG found various conditions imposed on buyers, including for delay in possession and in the undertaking given with application, were one sided and "can be considered unfair".

According to the minority order, the imposition of unfair and discriminatory condition by a dominant player has serious adverse effects on the market and on consumers.

Jaypee collected several thousands of crores of rupees from the consumers on the pretext of offering residential units in 'integrated townships' and "cannot now be allowed to turn around and say that it is a 'marketing gimmick' when it is subjected to the scrutiny of this Commission", the two dissenting members said in their order.

The proposed penalty of Rs 665.94 crore translates into 5 per cent of the company's average three-year annual turnover.

There was no immediate comment from the company.

The penalty amount, if it had not been overruled, would have been the biggest imposed by fair trade regulator CCI on a real estate player.

The regulator had slapped a fine of Rs 630 crore on DLF in November 2012 and the ruling was first challenged in Compat and is now before the Supreme Court.

Latest Realty News

Oct 29, 2015
Oberoi Realty has launched a 25-acre residential project in Mumbai's Borivali called 'Sky City'.
Oct 29, 2015
NEW DELHI: Government departments involved in granting approvals for construction projects in cities and towns will now come out with necessary notifications by November-end for streamlining approvals for time-bound and hassle-free clearances. This will mean applicants don't have to bring their cases to Delhi for different clearances.
Oct 28, 2015
New Delhi: Realty firm Tata Housing has sold 250 flats, worth over Rs 100 crore, from its housing project at Goa.
Oct 28, 2015
New Delhi: Realty firm Bhasin Group on Tuesday said it will invest Rs 150 crore on construction of a 33-storey commercial tower in Noida in mere 99 days, a sort of record for the national capital region.
Oct 27, 2015
Mumbai: Housing Development and Infrastructure Ltd (HDIL), a leading Mumbai-based real estate developer is all set to launch two mega projects in Virar (East) and Ghatkopar (East). The company will launch the first phase of its affordable housing project 'Planet HDIL' – mega smart city in Virar (East), this Diwali and another two luxurious projects in Ghatkopar (East), by end of 2015.
Oct 27, 2015
KOLKATA: Office space transactions in Kolkata fell by 30% from the last quarter. According to the Research and Forecast Report by Colliers International, the recorded office space transaction volume stood at 0.2 million sq ft in the third quarter of 2015.
Oct 27, 2015
New Delhi: In cases of sale of flats, transfer of title after the issuance of occupancy certificate will not attract service tax, the Finance Ministry said on Monday.
Oct 27, 2015
PUNE: On a humid weekday afternoon last month, Sunil Thube wiped his brow, sipped his tea, and glanced every few seconds at his iPhone ringing impatiently. He answered a couple of calls and gave updates on land deals he was working on.
Oct 26, 2015
NASHIK: The Confederation of Real Estate Developers' Association of India (CREDAI) has decided to conduct business to business (B2B) meetings with real estate brokers in Nashik and Mumbai in a bid to boost real estate sector in Nashik, which has been passing through a phase of recession.
Oct 26, 2015
Bhubaneswar: Real estate developers in the state are pinning hopes on the state’s new housing policy combined with the recent Reserve Bank of India(RBI) decision to increase loan to value(LTV) ratio to revive the sluggish housing market in the festival season.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's