DLF has lost Gurgaon village land second time
It's the second time DLF has lost control of this controversial piece of land on which an 18-hole golf course and housing project was coming up
Sep 11, 2014
Source : The Times of India


CHANDIGARH: The fine print of the Punjab and Haryana high court's September 3 order cancelling the auction that saw real estate major DLF being allotted 350 acres of land in Gurgaon has revealed a startling fact. A major chunk of the land in question was with DLF and its sister companies in 1991. It was acquired through an exchange with the Wazirabad village panchayat. But the high court quashed it on technical grounds.

So, it's the second time DLF has lost control of this controversial piece of land on which an 18-hole golf course and housing project was coming up. The detailed judgment, a copy of which is with TOI, observes, "Possible undertones of the entire process being initiated to favour DLF may be discernible".

The 93-page judgment has mentioned that after the land had been handed back to the panchayat by the high court, the state government acquired it for a recreational project and engaged consultant PGA Design. The company concluded that such a project could be undertaken by the government or its agencies.

The government then appointed IL&FS, a company involved with DLF in other projects, as consultants. IL&FS eventually recommended that the project be handed over to a private enterprise and laid down the procedure that should be followed. The government accepted these recommendations.

"This stage, in fact, is where the "paradigm shift" in favour of DLF took place, in our opinion, with M/s IL&FS being appointed as consultants, without any open process, but simply on a decision by the board/committee (of the government)," the judgment says.

The judges also questioned the fresh bidding process and objected to the easy arrangements made for DLF to pay for the land. "Next factor in the chain of events, which is too coincidental to our mind, is the ouster of the other two bidders at the stage of the technical bid itself," the judgment notes.

It goes on to say that although DLF paid a sum of Rs 1,703 crore for the land at Rs 4.86 crores per acre, it was allowed to pay the money over eight years in largely bi-annual installments till February 2017.

"We find it difficult to approve out rightly the perpetual transfer of a huge chunk of 350 acres of prime land falling in the heart of the National Capital Region (NCR) to a private enterprise, at a rate which, as a lump-sum sounds extremely 'credit worthy', but eventually does not even factor in the normal increase in price for a period of eight years. That is not something, which we can overlook by any yardstick, seen together with the other circumstances," the court said.

Latest Realty News

Redevelop all unused plots in industrial areas’
Sep 11, 2014
If all goes according to plan, the civic body may soon convert all defunct industrial plots for commercial or residential use
PMC court orders part demolition of 4 buildings
Sep 11, 2014
The Patna Municipal Corporation (PMC) court on Wednesday ordered demolition of illegal parts of four buildings in the city within a month
Plot owners may get max 5 years to start construction
Sep 11, 2014
Landowners in Greater Noida will be hit hard if the Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority (GNIDA) changes its building bylaws
Govt Keen to Develop Smart Cities, Says Sorake
Sep 11, 2014
The State government on Wednesday held a preliminary meeting with representatives of various IT companies to develop ‘Smart Cities’
Can't Direct Govt to Acquire Land, says High Court
Sep 11, 2014
A High Court division bench headed by Chief Justice D H Waghela has denied permission to a woman who wanted to develop her piece of land near the Srirangapatna fort
City Encroachments Razed Amid Protest
Sep 11, 2014
Amid fierce protest by the locals, civic authorities demolished about 60 permanent structures encroaching on a stretch of road in GGP Colony here on Wednesday
Lens on Artha flat ‘owners’
Sep 11, 2014
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is now trying to identify influential people, who have taken flats from the Artha Tatwa (AT) group
BDA whip on truant builders
Sep 11, 2014
Real-estate developers engaging in unethical practices and making false promises will find themselves in trouble as the development authority has decided to stop the practice of conditional approval of building plans
Thumbs up to Tata township
Sep 11, 2014
Stakeholders of Jamshedpur today chose industrial township status with Tata Steel as civic guardian over the alternative of Jharkhand taking over the city under a municipality
Investors caught in ‘realty’ tangle
Sep 11, 2014
Investors willing to put their money in the new capital of Andhra Pradesh confront a fresh confusion. The uncertainty over exact location of the capital kept them on the hold for a long time

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's