Developers will have to pay 5% VAT, rules Supreme Court
Wherever the agreements have been clear on the levy of VAT, developers will be able to recover their payments
Sep 27, 2013
Source : The Economic Times


MUMBAI: In a major setback to realty developers , the Supreme Court has upheld the earlier Bombay High Court verdict that asked builders to pay 5% value-added tax for sale of underconstruction houses between 2006 and 2010 in Maharashtra.

The Supreme Court had clubbed all 26 appeals under consideration on this issue together . Of these appeals, 14 were from Karnataka and 12 from Maharashtra. The verdict will mean that developers in states such as Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh and Karnataka where VAT has been levied on such transactions will have to pay the charges.

"We do not find any error in the view of the (Bombay) High Court in this regard," said the order passed by the threejudge division bench. The bench comprised Justice RM Lodha, Justice J Chelameswar and Justice Madan B Lokur .

Moreover, the Advocate General for Maharashtra clearly stated before us that implementation of Rule 58(1-A ) (of Maharashtra VAT) shall not result in double taxation and in any case all claims of alleged double taxation will be determined in the process of assessment of each individual case." MVAT rule 58 (1-A ) provides for deduction of expenses on labour and service charges for the execution of the work related to the goods that has already been transferred.

"Wherever the agreements have been clear on the levy of VAT, developers will be able to recover their payments. However , there could be a rise in issues between developers and home buyers where agreements were silent on the VAT levy and who will bear these charges," said Hitesh Jain, senior partner, ALMT Legal.

Given that the property market between 2006 and 2010 was witnessing a boom with an exception of around 15-18 months, tax collection from Mumbai and Pune alone may surpass even . 1,000 crore, experts said. In 2006, the Maharashtra government had imposed a 5% VAT on apartments sold following an order of the Supreme Court in the case of K Raheja versus the government of Karnataka .

The Maharashtra government subsequently reduced VAT on sale of flats to 1% from April 1, 2010. In 2007, the realtors had received a stay on the circular asking them to pay 5% VAT since June 2006. Last year, the Bombay High Court had dismissed the plea filed by Builders Association of India.

Latest Realty News

Sale of residential property and tax
Sep 27, 2013
BANGALORE: A sale of property has tax implications. Before deciding on selling your property, you must analyse the tax implications as well. Capital gains tax is leviable when you sell a property. The gains arising out of the transfer of a property is the difference between the amount spent on its acquisition including the amount spent on improvement of the property, and the consideration received on its transfer. The excess over the amount spent is the capital gains.
Impact of inflation on home loan
Sep 27, 2013
BANGALORE: Over the past few years, home loan interest rates have steadily crept upwards. Everyone blamed it on inflation. In past few months, the rates have steadied after minor downwards rate revisions by the central bank. What happens during inflation?
Affordable housing to be main attraction at GIHED
Sep 27, 2013
AHMEDABAD: Affordable housing seems to be the flavour of the three-day property show by Gujarat Institute of Housing and Estate Developers (GIHED) which begins on 27th September. About 70 developers will showcase residential, commercial and plotting projects.
North Bangalore – Emerging residential destination
Sep 27, 2013
BANGALORE: Bangalore north has become the epicentre of the city with the presence of the international airport in Devanahalli. A host of civic infrastructure projects to upgrade connectivity and promote seamless travel are further enhancing the dynamics of this region.
Experts say pay VAT only if sale deed mentions it
Sep 27, 2013
MUMBAI: The SC was hearing 26 appeals against VAT on sale of flats, of which 12 were from Maharashtra and the rest from Karnataka while upholding the states’ right to impose VAT. The verdict means flats sold since July 1, 2006 will be liable for payment of the tax, unless the building was issued an Occupancy Certificate before the sale agreement.
Morgan Stanley arm shelves project with Wadhwa Group
Sep 27, 2013
MUMBAI: Morgan Stanley Real Estate Fund was working on the structured finance deal with Mumbai based Wadhwa Group since January to invest in the latter's 1.6 million square feet office project in Bandra-Kurla Complex. Construction on the project, called ONE BKC, is due to be completed in the next 12-15 months.
35 illegal floors of Campa Cola may be razed on Oct 3
Sep 27, 2013
MUMBAI: The last vestiges of hope for embattled residents of the upscale Campa Cola society in Worli appears to be lost. The BMC’s building proposal department has “on legal grounds” rejected their proposal to regularize those sections of the society that fall within the permissible floor space index (FSI) limit. The BMC plans to raze 35 illegal floors across seven buildings on October 3, instead of the earlier plan of October 2 owing to Gandhi Jayanti.
‘Hiba valid for property transfer’
Sep 27, 2013
HYDERABAD: The AP State Minorities Commission (APSMC) on 25th September issued notices to various government agencies instructing them to accept the Hiba (oral gift) as a valid method of transferring immovable properties.
Housing to get costlier on 30% hike in cement prices
Sep 27, 2013
MUMBAI: After witnessing a price correction in all major markets owing to sluggish demand, cement prices have increased by over 30% in a month to Rs 275 for each 50kg bag. With the trend expected to continue, a cement bag is likely to cost over Rs 325 this festive season, hitting the ailing realty sector and making it costlier to purchase that dream home.
Social infrastructure for quality life
Sep 27, 2013
MUMBAI: Buying a suitable house that fits in their budget is no doubt very important for home buyers. However, equally vital are the educational, health, transport, security, cultural and recreational facilities for quality living, which range from grocery stores and markets to banks, schools, hospitals, theatres, restaurants, clubs, religious places, etc. “Buyers have always had a holistic approach and they prefer to have schools, hospitals, shopping complexes, entertainment centres, etc., in c

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's