Hotel Taj Mansingh: Home ministry opposes right of first refusal to Tatas
The home ministry said "that the proposal to allow IHCL to have the 'first right of refusal' in the public auction has not been provided for in the lease deed
Jun 29, 2013
Source : The Economic Times


DELHI: The union home ministry has said that the Tatas should not be allowed the right of first refusal in the upcoming auction of the Indian Hotels Company-operated Taj Mansingh hotel, opposing the proposal of the New Delhi Municipal Council, which owns the building that houses the luxury hotel in central Delhi.

In a letter to NDMC on May 10, the home ministry said "that the proposal to allow IHCL to have the 'first right of refusal' in the public auction has not been provided for in the lease deed. A provision of 'first right of refusal' will result in lower bids in the public auction. Therefore, the ministry of home affairs is of the opinion that 'first right of refusal' should not be allowed to IHCL in the proposed auction and fresh lease should be granted by open public auction." ET has reviewed a copy of the letter.

The home ministry's views are important since it is the administrative ministry for the municipal body, which has to find a new operator for the hotel by October this year.

Following the development, the civic body has decided to seek the opinion of the Solicitor General of India. "We will seek his opinion through the ministry of home affairs and the urban development ministry, on how to move forward with respect to the lease, considering there are cases pending in the Delhi High Court and Supreme Court," the spokesman for NDMC, AK Mishra, said.

A spokeswoman for the Indian Hotels Company LtdBSE 1.27 %, which runs the Taj hotels and operates the Taj Mansingh hotel under a lease with NDMC, declined to comment as the matter is sub judice. The 33-year lease ended in October 2011 after which the civic body decided to extend the lease with the existing operator for one more year. During this period, the civic body had appointed Ernst & Young to value the property and to find a way forward. E&Y, in its report, suggested auctioning the property, with the first right of refusal resting with Taj.

In its meeting in last September, NDMC had decided to opt for an auction giving the right of first refusal to Taj, while extending the company's lease by another year up to October 2013.

BJP legislator Karan Singh Tanwar, who is a member of the council, blamed the government for the mess. "An open auction should happen in this case but it looks like council members are trying to take another route. The ministry of home affairs has said that first right of refusal will mean loss of revenue," he said .

In April this year, IHCL had filed an injunction suit in the Delhi High Court ahead of a possible auction of the property's lease by the government agency in order to protect its position. The company had claimed part ownership of the Taj Mansingh hotel, which is contrary to NDMC's claim that was also verified by consultant firm Ernst & Young. IHCL claimed that it too had invested in the property when it was built in the late 1970s and, therefore, is a rightful joint owner.

On January 15, IHCL's chief executive officer, Raymond Bickson had told ET: "It was a bare shell project that was stopped (by NDMC), and we had put in all the money to build it. I guess over the long term, we will get it straightened out."

Latest Realty News

Balasore cops secure remand of ATG CMD for two days
Jun 29, 2013
BHUBANESWAR: Sahadevkhunta police in Balasore were on Friday granted the remand of Artha Tatwa Group CMD Pradip Sethi and Director Manoj Patnaik for interrogation. The duo was shifted from Jharpada jail in Bhubaneswar to Balasore jail on Thursday night.
Akhilesh Yadav meets Japanese delegation to explore funding for Metro rail
Jun 29, 2013
LUCKNOW: The state government has begun considering loan options for Lucknow Metro rail project after giving green signal to its first phase. On Friday, chief minister Akhilesh Yadav held a closed door meeting with the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)'s India chief, Shinya Ejima and deputy chief representative of India, Ichiguchi Tomohide along with other senior officials of the international agency.
Bubble in the making?
Jun 29, 2013
DELHI: If you travel on the road to Noida and Greater Noida, you will find a large number of banners and hoardings of new residential real estate projects on both sides of the road. The moment you get close to construction sites, salesmen of property dealers descend on you like a horde of bees. Start talking to them and you will be offered discounts of up to 9 per cent on the published price straightaway. Most developers have thrown in freebies like free parking bay and club memberships. It is a
Won’t allow high-rises in Delhi as long as I’m alive: Sheila
Jun 29, 2013
DELHI: Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit on Friday continued to oppose Urban Development Minister Kamal Nath’s push for vertical growth in the city, saying she will not allow construction of high-rise buildings as long as she is alive.
Green buildings in India: Hyderabad spearheads the change
Jun 29, 2013
HYDERABAD: The future of real estate strongly associates with ‘Green Buildings’. Despite the fact that almost all real estate developers acknowledge it, only a handful of them are able to follow. Launching a green project, from a real estate developer’s perspective, is commercially unviable and thus not necessary. And they are right to a large extent. Since green projects require a relatively higher level of initial capital expenditure, developers find it difficult to go ahead unless they are su
Rupee depreciation may boost NRI investments in realty sector
Jun 29, 2013
MUMBAI: The depreciation in rupee provides a psychological boost to both non-resident Indians as well as developers, real estate consultancy firm Cushman & Wakefield said.
Construction delays make buyers pick resale homes
Jun 29, 2013
BANGALORE | DELHI:New home sales may be few and far between, but resale of properties is booming. Sale of such properties is up 40% across the country in the last six to eight months as buyers become more risk-averse looking at the enormous construction delays, property brokers and financial institutions say.
Tumkur Road industrial belts push realty growth in Bangalore
Jun 28, 2013
BANGALORE: Bangalore west has primarily developed over the years into a residential hub with Rajajinagar, Basaveshwaranagar, Malleswaram, Yeshwanthpur, Mathikere, Mahalakshmi Layout, Nandhini Layout and Chandra Layout being some of the prominent localities.
ORR connectivity makes it a corporate destination in Bangalore
Jun 28, 2013
BANGALORE: The Outer Ring Road (ORR) is a veritable example of the kind of realty development that can take place if access and infrastructure are put in place. The ORR has not only become the most favoured address for IT Special Economic Zones (SEZ) and large retail brands, it is also the destination of residential units catering to the workforce employed in these IT companies.
Buy a home only when you are ready
Jun 28, 2013
BANGALORE: The right time to take a home loan is when you want to buy a house. After all, a loan is a means to an end. You should not time your purchase of property based on the interest rate cycle. This is even true for floating rate loans (and 95 percent plus home loans are on floating rate basis). After all, in theory at least, if the interest rates drop in the future, you will get the benefit of the rate drop at that time.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's