Late delivery, errant builders leave buyers flat broke in Mumbai
Buyers who booked flats worth Rs 20-50 crore are still waiting for their homes
Oct 06, 2014
Source : The Times of India
Bombay Municipal Corporation


Mumbai: In central Mumbai, buyers who booked flats worth Rs 20-50 crore are still waiting for their homes because the project is stuck in litigation for the past three years.

In Juhu, people who paid up to Rs 15 crore are stranded after the BMC issued a stop-work notice to the builder for manipulations in the building plan

In Oshiwara, a luxury residential project is stalled because of a dispute between the two partners.

Early this year, a group of 124 flat owners in Versova held a dharna against the developer for delaying the project by a couple of years.

Despite assurances, promises and agreements, beleaguered flat buyers face an uphill task when builders fail to deliver on time. Property market sources said the delay in handing over possession is rampant. Purchasers who have invested their life savings in a home find it extremely difficult to take on powerful developers. Moreover, seldom do builders pay interest to buyers for the delay.

Many such affected buyers have formed support groups, sent legal notices to errant builders, held dharnas outside their offices and have even approached politicians for help.

"Due to one-sided sale agreements tilted in a developer's favour, buyers have no option but to be patient when the developer delays his project. There have been numerous cases of late possession where delays have stretched beyond two years. However, when an end user who is not financially strong, has to bear the brunt of pre-EMIs as well as rental for his temporary accommodation, it tends to get out of hand,'' said Gulam Zia, ED, Knight Frank India.

In a few cases, more so up north in NCR, buyers have come together and forced the developers to give in to their legitimate demands. "In stark contrast, we don't hear of such consumer unrest in Mumbai. This is essentially due to constantly increasing prices that discourage the end-users from pulling out and investing in another project. So, in Mumbai, those who suffer inordinate delays draw consolation from the fact that the price appreciation makes up for most of the delays. The solution to all these problems can come only out of an equitable sale agreement. A housing regulator is thus emerging as the need of the hour,'' he added.

Lawyer Anil Harish, who is a specialist in the field of real estate, said builders start selling apartments even before work starts. "There could be several reasons for a stalled project. Either the builder has run out of funding or the authorities have issued a stop-work notice for violations. Sometimes, the developer wants to change the building plans or there may be delay in procuring approvals,'' he said.

Harish said the new state housing regulatory authority may offer hope to flat buyers; draft rules stipulate compensation for victims with interest and cases to be decided within three months. "However, the builder should be charged a minimum 15% interest or the compensation should be equivalent to the rent that the buyer may have got from the apartment,'' he added.

Lawyer Rajesh Gehani, who represents flats buyers of an Oshiwara project, said each police station must constitute a special cell for cases pertaining to cheating and breach of trust. "Unfortunately, the delay in dispensing justice works in favour of the law-breakers,'' he said, adding, "It is unfortunate that people have to shell out money (to pursue the case) to recover their own hard-earned money."

A developer said delays could be because of several reasons: "It could be due to a builder's sheer incompetence or as he is under financial stress or entangled in some litigation.''

But there could be circumstances beyond the developer's control too. "He may face sudden shortage of material and labour. There could be government hurdles in procuring approvals and failure of service providers like the local municipal authority,'' he added.

"No respectable builder wants a delay. It's not beneficial, but sometimes out of his control,'' said the developer, cautioning buyers to read the fine print and the developer's track record before investing in the project. He hoped that the new housing regulatory bill will quickly resolve this issue.

Pranay Vakil, chairman at Praron Consultancy, blamed the change in the development control rules in Mumbai in 2012 for many of the stalled projects. "Suddenly, the new law mandated payment of a hefty premium by builders who planned to avail of extra floor space index. This led to disputes between the land owner and the developer as to who would pick up the tab. So, the flat buyer became the fall guy,'' he said. There are buildings ready with occupation certificates and buyers who have paid the full amount. "Yet, possession is not given because the builder now wants more money from the buyer,'' added Vakil.

Market sources said labour and dealing with various contractors and their coordination is also a major issue. "The BMC issues stage-wise commencement certificates. This also causes delay. Inadequate cash flow and lesser sales could also hamper speed of construction,'' they added.

Latest Realty News

Reits may not get complete pass-through status
Oct 06, 2014
Contrary to a promise made in the Budget for 2014-15, the proposed real estate investment trusts (Reits) might not get a full pass-through status
DDA Housing scheme 2014: Hurry!!! Only 5 days left to apply for flats
Oct 06, 2014
Have you applied for the DDA flats? If yes, then we wish good luck to you, but if you still haven't applied and wish to own a dream home in the form of a DDA flat, then, please hurry as the ambitious scheme will only last for 5 days, till October 9
Muslim apartments highlight housing segregation in India
Oct 06, 2014
Gulistaan Golf View Heights, a planned apartment compound on the outskirts of New Delhi, promises all the amenities middle-class Indian homebuyers typically seek in a property development
No full house in real estate show
Oct 05, 2014
The arrhythmia of Greater Noida's housing market is not a boom-bust cycle of rising prices followed by a sharp correction, but rather a prolonged slump of low prices and low demand
Builders lap up loans despite a slowing real estate markets
Oct 04, 2014
Even as the demand for loans from corporates is slumping to a decade low, commercial real estate and construction are outperforming at nearly triple the average despite slowing real estate market which is raising concerns
SBI announces revised, liberal home loan scheme for staff
Oct 04, 2014
State Bank of India has revised housing loan scheme for employees
Fair Value Hike may Drag Housing Sector into Deep Trouble
Oct 04, 2014
The State Government’s decision to hike the fair value of land by 50 per cent will have a negative impact on the real estate sector, which has already become stagnant due to the high price of land and houses
US private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts to invest Rs 750 crore in 2 realty projects in metros
Oct 03, 2014
US private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co has made its entry in the country's real estate sector by finalising investments of Rs 750 crore
Hines Launches $250 Million Hines India Residential Program Set to Focus on Multifamily Projects in ...
Oct 03, 2014
India—International real estate firm Hines recently announced the launch of its Hines India Residential initiative
Festival time for banks as customers return
Oct 03, 2014
Going by the numbers so far, the ongoing festive season could turn out to be a busy one for bankers looking to lend to consumers for big- ticket items like homes and cars

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's