Mumbai's desire for height
Centre should allow local authorities to take the final call
Jun 03, 2013
Source : Business Standard


MUMBAI: Mumbai's real estate is among the most expensive in the world. Partly, of course, this is a result of geographical factors - the city is limited by natural boundaries of sea, hills and marshland. Partly it is due to subversion of the real estate market by well-connected builders. But, above all, it is a function of artificially constrained supply. Mumbai has always been the most vertical of India's cities; and it should perhaps be more vertical still, in order to help ease its yawning deficit in floor space. Mumbai today has fewer square metres of floor space available per resident than almost all other major world cities. A more vertical city would not only ease that constraint, but also make commuting in Mumbai less of a nightmare; today, because of the lack of availability of housing units close to their workplaces, Mumbai's residents have among the longest average travel times in the world.


It, therefore, could be argued that the ministry of environment and forests should look favourably upon the Maharashtra government's demand that it ease certain restrictions on vertical building that it has imposed. In particular, the MoEF requires the height of a building to be linked to the width of a road - for example, a 60-metre high building must be on a 30-metre wide road. The MoEF's logic is that this is necessary to reduce congestion. However, the consequences of such rigid rule-making are severe. While such an approach does little to address problems like congestion through better traffic planning and management, it also reduces the ability of a city to meet its inhabitants' demands for more space - and actually stresses infrastructure further as people commute longer and longer distances.


In any case, the question must be asked: why, precisely, is the MoEF creating rules for what surely should be a decision taken at a more local level? The ministry is insufficiently accountable to the people of Mumbai for this restriction to come from it. In addition, it is far from clear why a city-planning decision should be made by a ministry that's supposed to look at environmental considerations. As it is, the ministry's reputation for delays in clearances is not enviable - not entirely its fault, given the number of such clearances required and the pace at which they are being applied for. Nevertheless, the MoEF has sought to increase its domain and Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan is right to point out that Mumbai's development and its people's aspirations for more space cannot be held hostage to a single ministry's concerns.


In general, decisions on how vertical or not a city should be are better left to local authorities, which should be made more accountable to the people of the city they supervise. Some cities, like Delhi, may manage to expand more horizontally. Others, like Mumbai, may need to go vertical. There is no one-size-fits-all method. The Centre could frame model guidelines on such matters, but should ideally allow the local authorities to take a more considered view depending on specific conditions on the ground.

Latest Realty News

Realty pile-up doubles in NCR, Mumbai, Hyderabad
Jun 03, 2013
Tough times are far from over for the real estate sector. The inventory pile-up across the National Capital Region (NCR), Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) and Hyderabad have almost doubled in the last three years, signalling the market is to yet recover.
Economically backward class to get 'green homes'
Jun 03, 2013
As many as 184 homeless families in Malappuram can reside in their 'green houses' as the municipality will soon inaugurate the flats constructed for economically backward families, under the Integrated Housing and Slum Development Programme ( IHSDP) project
The agent who can save a deal
Jun 03, 2013
Amit wanted to sell his apartment in Mumbai and approached a real estate agent. His dealer took more than six months and was still unable to sell the property.
Hidco eyes rich harvest by plot sale
Jun 03, 2013
fter reaping rich harvest last year by selling off lands, The Housing Infrastructure and Development Corporation (Hidco) has again put up several commercial plots for sale.
DLF to invest about Rs 3,000 crore to build new projects in FY'14
Jun 02, 2013
Realty major DLF LtdBSE -5.41 % will invest about Rs 3,000 crore this fiscal on construction of various projects and is targeting sales booking of more than Rs 6,000 crore.
Property sellers without PAN face 20% tax hit
Jun 02, 2013
Those selling immovable property without disclosing their permanent account number ( PAN) are in for a tough time with the government mandating a 20% tax deduction at source (TDS) in such transactions.
Housing Development & Infrastructure Ltd served termination notice from MIAL
Jun 01, 2013
Housing Development & Infrastructure Ltd (HDIL) has received a termination notice from Mumbai International Airport Limited (MIAL) for its slum rehabilitation project, it said on Wednesday.
North Chennai home rates grow fastest
Jun 01, 2013
Northern parts of Chennai have long been considered the backwater region of the city. But the residential price index (residex) put out by the National Housing Bank (NHB) shows that Ayanavaram, Kolathur and Purasawalkam have seen the maximum appreciation in residential prices in the last six years across the country.
Luxury brands now get more room for growth in malls
Jun 01, 2013
Mall developers in India are setting aside up to 40% space for luxury brands, hoping to tap new money by offering labels such as Jimmy Choo, Canali and Gucci alongside mass-market products.
GMR infra back in the black with Rs 519 crore profit
Jun 01, 2013
Infrastructure major GMR Group Friday reported a consolidated net profit of `519.17 crore for the quarter ended March, 2013 as against a net loss of `366 crore in the corresponding quarter.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's