Policymakers must release land
But it has to be done without triggering political agitations or crises in banking and real estate
Feb 17, 2015
Source : Business Standard


New Delhi: "This time it's different" - those words are often spoken to justify prices hitting high levels, and staying there against all logic. It is true that every bull market has its special characteristics, though that doesn't make any uptrend permanently sustainable. In this bull market, equity has risen, while real estate has fallen. That divergence is unusual. The real estate sector is struggling.

Since January 2012, the CNX Realty Index has returned 23 per cent, while the has returned 87 per cent. Multiple commercial and housing projects are stalled. Developers are cash-strapped and many have been forced to make asset sales. The US subprime crisis   showed how catastrophic losses can be when real estate bubbles burst. The American market went topsy-turvy. In some urban areas, it became cheaper for somebody looking to rent for a given period to take out a mortgage and default instead.

Land prices should relate to productivity, which rises as usage gets more sophisticated. A rice field generates less income than an automobile plant or a luxury hotel and land prices should reflect that. On a large scale, 30 per cent of India's population lives in cities, which occupy far less area than India's villages. But cities produce 70 per cent of GDand urban land is worth much more. But at some point, value addition saturates. For example, a luxury hotel might maximise potential returns from given acreage. Beyond that saturation point, bubbles might result. It might not be obvious when "value-saturation" will be hit.

There's a need to assess both legal issues and external factors carefully when looking at conversion. For example, a developer may try to convert an orchard into a factory or an apartment block. If he cannot do this due to legal issues, value saturation is hit. Even so, the orchard will be more productive if infrastructure improves. Better power and roads will allow fruit to be sold with less spoilage. Real estate project timeframes can be long and uncertain. For example, textile mills were shut in 1982 in what used to be central Bombay. These were re-developed 20-25 years later after multiple legal battles, to host Mumbai's posh new offices and nightclubs.

Complicated laws create scarcity and contribute to bubbles. Rent control acts, land ceiling acts, sundry environmental and other statutory clearances and other laws are all barriers to efficient land-usage and conversion. This is why Indian land prices match First World prices. Expensive, scarce land also means poor infrastructure. Bubbles can deflate or burst. There were corrections of 25-35 per cent in urban real estate prices in the mid-1990s. A huge bubble started to inflate in the 2000s as banks started offering mortgages. The past two or three years have seen prices stagnate, with some corrections.

Rampant tax evasion means land is officially under-valued. Getting accurate prices is difficult. Real estate developers operate on high leverage. They buy land (often borrowing cash or making part payment). They raise money to build by pre-selling to buyers. Housing demand has flattened and interest rates are high. Developers often borrow at very high rates. There are rumours that the NSEL scam (which featured speculation in non-existent commodities contracts) was triggered by real estate players seeking alternate borrowing mechanisms.

The Reserve Bank of India is wary of loans backed by real estate. Banks are reluctant to lend to developers. When banks do lend against real estate as in mortgages, they discount considerably. Bank exposure to real estate is quite high, nevertheless. So is bank exposure to infrastructure projects which are stalled due to land-related issues. There's an interesting conundrum. India needs better infrastructure, which means land must be acquired quickly, at reasonable prices. But if land prices drop and supply increases, banks must review real estate exposures, and developers must revalue land banks. Of course, bank exposures to infrastructure projects will also become less risky.

If land is forcibly acquired, Singur-style agitations can happen, or even Maoist insurgencies. The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, laid down consent norms and social impact norms to enable acquisition. This Act has been amended by Ordinance to remove the necessity for consent and social impact assessment in several categories.

It will be hard to get the ordinance ratified by Parliament but it would be a very positive signal for investors if it does pass. One way or another, policymakers must release land, without triggering political agitations or crises in banking and real estate. If this is possible, prospects will dramatically improve for infrastructure, real estate and construction.

Latest Realty News

Feb 17, 2015
Mumbai: Realty players have welcomed the the BrihanMumbai Municipal Corporation's proposal to increase floor space index (FSI) up to 8
Feb 17, 2015
MUMBAI: At a time when consultants are being poached by start-ups and corporate strategy teams, the Mumbai-based real estate company Lodha Group has created the biggest team of management consultants
Feb 17, 2015
NEW DELHI: The government is in the process of preparing a fresh cabinet note outlining the contours of a real estate regulator
Feb 17, 2015
New Delhi: The Delhi Development Authority saw approval of chapters on environment and transport in Master Plan 2021
Feb 17, 2015
Mallapuram: Commercial building owners under the banner of the Kerala Building Owners Welfare Association are on a warpath against the civic bodies
Feb 17, 2015
Raichur: The State government had zero-tolerance policy on encroachments, Minister For Urban Development Vinay Kumar Sorake said
Feb 17, 2015
NEW DELHI: Housing prices in Delhi-NCR rose by an average 3 per cent during October-December period of 2014
Feb 16, 2015
Bhubaneswar: Experts warn that excessive use of high radio frequency in the proposed Smart Cities might pose health risk
Feb 16, 2015
NOIDA: More than five months after the new contours of the no-construction zone around the Okhla Bird Sanctuary were finalized, a delay in the final notification is making thousands of homebuyers increasingly frustrated and restless
Feb 16, 2015
GURGAON: The state government has been accused of encroaching on private land in Dhankot to widen a state highway into a four-lane road

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's