Why India Inc is not happy with the new Land Bill
CEOs feel increased project cycles, compensation and litigation fears make any large infra projects unviable
Sep 17, 2013
Source : Business Standard


MUMBAI: Ajit Gulabchand, Chairman of infrastructure firm, HCC, is a worried man. After a lengthy court battle with the environment ministry which almost grounded HCC’s signature project in Lavasa city near Pune, Gulabchand says he will not start any new projects for the next two to three years.

The reason: The land Acquisition Bill passed by the Parliament last month will either make projects unviable or expensive for large infrastructure or real estate projects like Lavasa. And if any braveheart CEO does start land acquisition for a new project, says Gulabchand, he will be facing litigation at almost every step.

“It would be interesting to see how many projects manage to acquire land after this bill,” he says. 

Gulabchand is not alone. Almost every CEO -- planning a big infrastructure project to set up airports or steel which require large tracks of land - is saying the bill is not conducive for investments. 

And here are the reasons: As per the new bill, a new layer of approval by way of social impact assessment has to be undertaken. This will increase project life cycle at least by one year. And at every stage, it can be challenged at the court.

The provision of rehabilitation and resettlement (R&R) is now necessary for all affected families. The new law says that R&R will have to be completed before buying the land which will also add to project costs. Unlike the previous 1884 land bill, the new bill provides a house for every family displaced on the lines of Indira Awas Yojna or a minimum 50 square feet house in the urban areas.

If the family chooses not to accept the house, it would get a one-time financial grant or one-time grant of Rs 5 lakh per family. The land owner will also have the option to get annual payment of  Rs 2,000 a month for 20 years, to be adjusted for inflation. Further, an affected family also gets a monthly subsistence allowance equivalent to Rs 3,000 a month for one year from the date of award.

The new bill says consent of 80% of displaced people is required in case of acquisition by a private company and 70% of land owners consent in case of public-private partnerships. The new bill says land acquisition would lapse if no payments are made within 5 years.

In an earlier interview, L&T Chairman AM Naik had warned that the project cost of new airports near Mumbai will go up by Rs 4,500 crore in land cost alone.

“This will just lead to uncertainty on the ground as for every track of land 10% to 15% of land owners are untraceable. It will be difficult for a company to get consent from 80% of the people and project costs will go up” says CEO of a Birla group company asking not to be quoted.

Land costs make around 5% to 10% of total cost for large projects like steel and power but for airports, roads and townships, the land costs make up for upto 50% of project cost.

The new bill also says that if the land is not utilized for the stated purpose in five years, it will have to be returned to the government. This provision again is negative for infrastructure projects like Navi Mumbai airport project, which still needs to acquire another 600 acres from local landowners.

And finally, CEOs say the compensation amount of four times the land value in the rural area and two times of land value in urban area will increase the cost of projects two to three times.

The new bill says where the award has been made but acquisition has not been completed, compensation will now be paid according to the provisions of the new Bill. Also, where acquisition of land has not taken place for 10 years, the process for acquisition will need to be initiated afresh under the new bill or land has to be returned to the original holder or to the state government.

The ‘retrospective clause’ in the bill would disrupt the land acquisition process underway in various infrastructure and industrial projects.

“This bill will start new problems than solving old ones. The bill will just lead to litigation and project delays,” rues Gulabchand.


Latest Realty News

State to witness 6000 affordable houses soon
Sep 17, 2013
BHUBANESWAR: To meet the ever increasing demand of affordable houses, Credai­ Orissa, a body of real estate developers, is considering con­struction 0f 5,000-6,000 houses for lower and middle income groups in the next 2-3 years.
Spectre of bubble-burst looms over housing sector
Sep 17, 2013
MUMBAI: The year was 2007. The real estate market, like the Indian economy, was on a roll. And Manish Khanna was busy house-hunting in Mumbai. His weekends were spent looking for an affordable deal in a good locality.
Jaipur Development Authority struggles to rehabilitate house owners in nullah area
Sep 17, 2013
JAIPUR: Even after drafting a special rehabilitation policy, the Jaipur Development Authority (JDA) continues to struggle to rehabilitate the affected house-owners of Amanishah Nullah. Other than facing protests against the policy, a recent problem faced by JDA was in Kumawato Ki Dhani, Sanganer area. Here the authorities planned to rehabilitate 41 affected house-owners. An official said, "The additional chief judicial magistrate issued a stay on the project as a local farmer has claimed that th
BMC reworks FSI of tallest residential tower
Sep 17, 2013
MUMBAI: A high court-directed report prepared by the civic administration could force the developer of Palais Royale, touted as India's tallest residential tower, to rework its plan.
Doesn't BMC want us to pay property tax? System down as deadline nears
Sep 17, 2013
MUMBAI: The property tax payment deadline is just 15 days away, but the BMC's collection system has been on the blink since a week, hugely inconveniencing Mumbaikars. It may take afew more days to be up again.
BDA gives a shove to lake project in capital
Sep 17, 2013
BHUBANESWAR: The much-awaited lake project near Satya Nagar crematorium here has been put on fast track. The Bhubaneswar Development Authority (BDA) recently completed a survey of slum dwellers, residing at the proposed site. "It is an unauthorized slum. The slum dwellers will be rehabilitated in three transit accommodation centres in the city," BDA vice-chairman Vishal Dev said.
Does Vasai-Virar have the potential to become an independent city?
Sep 16, 2013
MUMBAI: With a corporation area of roughly 383 sq km and another 500 sq km of Taluka area, the Vasai-Virar region is being touted to become a city in itself. However, does having a large area alone suffice to convert a region into a self-sufficient city? It takes proper social and physical infrastructure along with well-developed connectivity to render a locality self-sufficient. With the inception of the Vasai-Virar Municipal Corporation (VVMC) in 2012, the Vasai-Virar region holds huge potenti
Beneficiaries smile ear-to-ear as PM Manmohan Singh gives them key to house
Sep 16, 2013
CHANDIGARH: A beaming Akhtar Ali showed with pride the keys of the one-room tenement that he and his wife had received from Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Saturday. A resident of a colony in Sector 52, Ali was among the 10 beneficiaries who received the keys Saturday. Several hundred others keenly inspected the houses that they were to be allotted.
Want to buy a house? Keep it on hold if you are not desperate
Sep 16, 2013
MUMBAI: Sumanta Rudra, head of infrastructure and administration at VFS Global, has decided to defer buying a property. "I am expecting a correction in property price. I will only take a call about buying after the elections."
Transfer your home loan in easy steps
Sep 16, 2013
HYDERABAD: If you are not happy with your existing Home Loan, then there is a ray of hope for you. Now you can transfer your loan to another bank. Loan Transfer or Refinancing of loan is an easy option through which most of the people nowadays are opting to take the benefit of lower interest rates prevailing in the market.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's