Will you have to pay VAT on your flat? SC ruling to push up property prices
Oct 14, 2013
Source : The Economic Times

 

BANGALORE: According to a recent verdict by the Supreme Court, the sale of a property that is under construction would be liable to value-added tax (VAT).

The ruling could have far-reaching ramifications for the real estate industry as well as property buyers. In the case of L&T versus State of Karnataka, the apex court held that the pre-construction agreements for sale of immovable property would qualify as 'works contract' and, therefore, VAT would be payable on the transaction.

It is likely that the judgement will push the states' VAT authorities to tax all transactions for properties that are under construction. This could also include the real estate transactions concluded in the past few years.

The judgement was pronounced by a larger bench of the Supreme Court, so the verdict shall be considered the law of the land until it is overruled by a constitutional bench of the apex court.

Though the case related to real estate operations in the southern and western parts of the country, the principles enunciated in this judgement are likely to impact the real estate industry throughout the country, which, in turn, would result in higher prices of property.

It is pertinent to note that this judge ment is merely an interpretation of an existing law. So, its applicability is likely to be with retrospective effect. The state VAT authorities may cash in on this opportunity and demand tax dues on past transactions from real estate players by invoking the extended period of limitation. While it is not possible to quantify the exact impact of judgement on the real estate industry, if implemented with retrospective effect, the demand for tax and interest is likely to run into thousands of crores of rupees.

Supreme Court ruling on the applicability of VAT to push up property prices

Buy constructed property

What this also means is that buyers may be better off purchasing fully constructed property compared with the one under construction.

Till now, constructed property has attracted only stamp duty, while the one under construction has also invited service tax. Now, the latter will also be subject to VAT.

It would be interesting to see how developers recover the VAT and interest from buyers, especially for past transactions.

While the robust contractual documents signed at the time of sale may empower the developer to recover the additional burden of VAT from the flat buyer, it may not be easy to recover the amount from the buyer if the possession has been handed over. There may also be cases where the original buyer has sold the flat to someone else and moved to another location. Tracking down such buyers will be an additional difficulty.

Besides, the valuation itself will be a challenge. The Supreme Court has specifically held that only goods incorporated by the developer after entering into an 'agreement to sell' the immovable property under construction would be subject to the VAT levy. It will not be easy to compute VAT on such a transaction.

This spells more trouble for an industry reeling from the slowdown in sales, rising inventories and dipping margins. It may be advisable for the real estate industry to engage with the state governments to arrive at a commercially feasible solution to settle the past tax dues, and a workable scheme for the payment of taxes (say, a composition rate of 1% in Maharashtra) in the future. This can help avoid undue litigation.

Setting off the input credit

Another aspect that merits the consideration of the real estate industry would be the manner in which it can set off the input tax credit of VAT paid on the procurement of raw material, against its output VAT liability for the past and the future.

It appears that the Supreme Court has ignored the fact that the sale of flats is already subject to stamp duty on the entire transaction value, as opposed to merely the value of land. Levying VAT on such transactions would now lead to multiplicity of taxes on the same transaction value.

Apart from this, the developers need to brainstorm to analyse the various schemes for payment of taxes available both under the Central and state tax laws, and decide a way forward appropriately.

Given the complexities of the issues, it is likely that the future will witness a series of litigation between the revenue authorities, the developer and the flat buyer. Needless to say, the biggest loser in the entire transaction chain will be the buyer, who will have to bear the burden of the increased cost.

 

 

Latest Realty News

NHB to get Rs 500-cr loan from UK for financing low-cost homes
Oct 14, 2013
DELHI: British government's Department for International Development will give National Housing Bank Rs 500-crore loan for financing construction of affordable houses in the country.
NHB's Rs 2,100 cr tax-free bonds to hit market soon : CMD
Oct 13, 2013
DELHI: The Rs 2,100-crore tax-free bond issue of National Housing Bank will hit the markets soon, a top official of the housing finance regulator said today.
Highway developers may have to pay penalty for delay in projects
Oct 13, 2013
DELHI: As the government readies to defer premium payments by the highway developers for under construction projects delayed due to regulatory hurdles, the concessionaires may also be liable for a penalty if the lag is found to be on their part.
Satellite picks up pace
Oct 13, 2013
KOLKATA: Rajarhat is a satellite city of Kolkata, which was planned in the 1990s. According to the master plan, it was supposed to be at least three times larger than Salt Lake City, a neighbouring well-established destination. Between 2003 and 2008, Rajarhat witnessed a lot of interest from various national and regional developers. Then the global financial crisis came, after which most of the plans either got stalled or pace of execution reduced considerably.
Shapoorji Pallonji to build on affordable housing segment
Oct 12, 2013
MUMBAI: It is a group that is synonymous with Mumbai’s high-end luxury and historic landmark buildings. Its list of projects includes the Taj and Oberoi hotels, the Brabourne Stadium, the RBI, World Trade Centre and the NCPA apartments.
Art for the home and hearth
Oct 12, 2013
CHENNAI: Janaki Hrishikesh, a Chennai resident, still remembers the first painting she brought. “It was a scene of Krishna’s rasaleela. We had just bought a house and were looking to decorate it. The painting practically drew us to it,” she says.
Government to issue ordinance to regularise illegal buildings
Oct 12, 2013
BANGALORE: The Karnataka government today decided to promulgate an ordinance to regularise byelaw deviations in residential and commercial buildings in urban areas of the state by collecting penalty, from the date of its assent by the Governor.
Real estate stocks gain on improving liquidity
Oct 11, 2013
MUMBAI: Real estate stocks have been gaining ground ever since the RBI announced measures to ease short-term liquidity. BSE Realty index outperformed the past month, gaining over 3.05% as compared to 1.2% gains on the BSE Sensex. Real estate stocks such as Unitech, DLF, Oberoi Realty gained anywhere between 1-8% the past month.
Realty stocks expected to move up
Oct 11, 2013
DELHI: Stocks of the beaten-down realty sector are expected to move up in the run-up to the results, said analysts. There could be an uptake of about 3-5% in these stocks going forward, they said.
Realtors bet on star power
Oct 11, 2013
DELHI: Deepika Padukone endorsing realty firm Ace Group is the latest entrant in the long list of celebrities and cricketers becoming brand ambassadors for developers, who are all out to attract buyers this festive season.

Latest Realty News Of State

Realty Talk's